Buying and selling gold and coins locally for 25 years!

Locations in Brookfield and Waukesha, WI

Mercury Head Dime (1943) Mercury Dimes, which neither depict the Greek god nor contain the chemical element were issued from 1916 to 1945. Franklin Silver Half Dollar (1963) No one foresaw the Mint ending production of the Franklin Silver Half Dollar after 1963. Kennedy's sudden assassination prompted his commemoration on all 50-cent pieces starting the following year. Morgan Silver Dollar (1889) Morgan dollars were first made in 1878, and stopped production in 1921. The value depends on certain rare dates and conditions. Remember, NEVER clean your coins! Silver Eagle (2004) Silver eagles are a popular way to invest in silver, and also make nice gifts. Proof condition eagles are encased in plastic and come with a government box. St. Gauden's $20 Double Eagle (1927) From 1907 to 1933, the St. Gauden Double Eagle enforced the gold standard in American currency. In 1933, production ceased when Franklin Roosevelt ordered the coins to be traded-in and replaced with paper money. Buffalo Nickel (1935) The Buffalo Nickel predates the Jefferson Nickel and is widely traded among numismatists. The coin's copper-and-nickel composition is particularly prone to wear, often leaving the date nearly indecipherable. Buffalo nickels are a popular start to a collection. Silver Bars More than just a precious metal, silver holds value thanks to a heavy industrial demand. These lustrous bars are easily handled, stacked, and stored. We handle 1 ounce, 10 ounce and 100 ounce sizes, along with 1 ounce rounds. Trading silver is made easier by the precise weights and purity measurements stamped directly into the bars.

Welcome to Greater Milwaukee Coin

Buy and Sell Gold, Rare Coins, and Currencies at Greater Milwaukee Coin


A currency’s value is based on confidence. So is our business. If you’re seeking an ethical, established local Milwaukee rare coin dealer, join the collectors and sellers who have trusted Greater Milwaukee Coin for years. We trade in both rare coins and precious metals, offering you a huge selection of collectable coins and gold and silver bullion for investment. We also pay the fairest pricing on your gold, coins, and jewelry.

Greater Milwaukee Coin is more than just our business, it’s our passion. Whether you’re looking to sell your jewelry or coins or add missing pieces to your large collection, our expert Milwaukee coin dealers and appraisers are here to help you. Greater Milwaukee Coin features the best prices on Milwaukee rare coins, paper money, platinum, silver and gold. We trade heavily in gold and silver bullion and all coins from wheat cents to silver dollars, including buffalo nickels, mercury dimes, Washington quarters, Franklin half dollars, and Morgan dollars, but we’re always interested in pricing your other US, foreign, or ancient rare coins and coin oddities.

Milwaukee Coin Services

Other Milwaukee coin shops and serious Milwaukee coin collectors come to us, and you should too! Our three locations deal in quantities ranging from very small to very large and our high volume of business allows us to work on the smallest profit margins. Greater Milwaukee Coin delivers you the best pricing on your US and foreign coins, diamonds, jewelry, dental gold, sterling silverware, tokens, medals, sterling bar sets and other coin related collectables. If you’re not sure what your coins are worth, don’t settle for pawn shop pricing. When you buy and sell gold or coins to our professional Milwaukee numismatists you’ll have the satisfaction of knowing you received a great price for your jewelry, coins or precious metals.

We offer a wide selection of books and other coin collector supplies. Our huge inventory and fair pricing have allowed us to become a trusted resource in the Wisconsin coin community. Stop by our Brookfield or Waukesha location to see our ever-changing inventory.

The local experts at Greater Milwaukee Coin are proud to celebrate exceptional Wisconsin coin dealing credentials and affiliations with the Professional Numismatists Guild (PNG), the American Numismatic Association (ANA), the Professional Coin Grading Service (PNG), Central States Numismatic Society, Numismatists of Wisconsin, South Shore Coin Club, Milwaukee Numismatic Society, Waukesha Coin Club, and the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation of America.

Experience the trusted service and expertise of Greater Milwaukee Coin. Sell Your Gold and Purchase Special Coins All At One Location! Contact the Milwaukee rare coin dealers at Greater Milwaukee Coin by calling 262-781-4200 today or stop by our Brookfield and Waukesha locations.
© Copyright 2020 Greater Milwaukee Coin
Greater Milwaukee Coin & Jewelry Exchange Inc BBB Business Review